• Business
    • Case Studies
    • Companies
    • Growth
    • Strategy
  • Functional
    • Finance
    • HR
    • Marketing
    • Science & Tech
  • Leadership
    • Be a Leader
    • Books
    • LDR Show
    • Leadership Nuggets
    • Movie Wisdom
    • Soundbytes
    • Women & Leadership
  • Personal
    • Character
    • Values
    • Competence
  • Soundbytes
  • Free E-mag
  • Videos
  • About Us
Leaderonomics.com
Leaderonomics.com
  • Business
    • Case Studies
      5 Ways Disruption Has Changed The World

      5 Ways Disruption Has Changed The World

      Don’t Waste Your Time On A Few Rotten Apples

      Don’t Waste Your Time On A Few Rotten Apples

      Thinking Out Of The Box: The Innovator’s Mind

      Thinking Out Of The Box: The Innovator’s Mind

      'Let's Rethink Our Approach To Education, And Collaborate To Compete!' Says Anne Tham

      'Let's Rethink Our Approach To Education, And Collaborate To Compete!' Says Anne Tham

    • Companies
      What We Can Learn From The Downfall Of Toys ‘R’ Us

      What We Can Learn From The Downfall Of Toys ‘R’ Us

      Top 15 SMEs From The AmBank BizRACE Spill The Beans

      Top 15 SMEs From The AmBank BizRACE Spill The Beans

      Making Your Dreams Come True For A Higher Purpose

      Making Your Dreams Come True For A Higher Purpose

      How Supply Chain Management Is Helping Malaysia Compete Internationally

      How Supply Chain Management Is Helping Malaysia Compete Internationally

    • Growth
      Lessons From 'Crazy Jack': An Extraordinary Leader In Style And Beliefs

      Lessons From 'Crazy Jack': An Extraordinary Leader In Style And Beliefs

      How The Right Strategy Can Help You Succeed In Business

      How The Right Strategy Can Help You Succeed In Business

      Want to Be a Self-Made Millionaire?

      Want to Be a Self-Made Millionaire?

      Lessons From The Experts: The Final AmBank BizCONFERENCE

      Lessons From The Experts: The Final AmBank BizCONFERENCE

    • Strategy
      To ‘Platform’ Or To Perish? That Is The Critical CEO Question!

      To ‘Platform’ Or To Perish? That Is The Critical CEO Question!

      Design Thinking As A Problem-Solving Tool

      Design Thinking As A Problem-Solving Tool

      How 30 Years Of Radical Decisions Have Kept Haier On Top

      How 30 Years Of Radical Decisions Have Kept Haier On Top

      Top 6 Digital Transformation Trends in Hospitality and Tourism

      Top 6 Digital Transformation Trends in Hospitality and Tourism

  • Functional
    • Finance
      Let’s Go Back To The Basics Of Financial Literacy, Shall We?

      Let’s Go Back To The Basics Of Financial Literacy, Shall We?

      The 10 Commandments Of Money

      The 10 Commandments Of Money

      How To Build A Successful Career In A Future Without Jobs

      How To Build A Successful Career In A Future Without Jobs

      Fourteen Embarrassing Questions You Were Afraid to Ask About Money

      Fourteen Embarrassing Questions You Were Afraid to Ask About Money

    • HR
      8 Steps To Create A More Effective Workforce

      8 Steps To Create A More Effective Workforce

      Here Are Some Creative Ways To Appreciate Your People

      Here Are Some Creative Ways To Appreciate Your People

      Stop Paying Your Employees To ‘Figure Out’ How To Get Work Done

      Stop Paying Your Employees To ‘Figure Out’ How To Get Work Done

      How Can HR Equip Talents For The Future Workforce?

      How Can HR Equip Talents For The Future Workforce?

    • Marketing
    • Science & Tech
      Does Every Company Need To Be A Technology Company?

      Does Every Company Need To Be A Technology Company?

      Raise Your Game: Staying Ahead In The Age of Automation

      Raise Your Game: Staying Ahead In The Age of Automation

      Can Tech Start-ups Stay Nimble While Growing?

      Can Tech Start-ups Stay Nimble While Growing?

      Are We Missing Something In Using AI To Enhance Customer Experience?

      Are We Missing Something In Using AI To Enhance Customer Experience?

  • Leadership
    • Be a Leader
      Is Failure A Crippling Blow Or Stepping Stone? You Decide.

      Is Failure A Crippling Blow Or Stepping Stone? You Decide.

      Which Of These Business Issues Can You Most Identify With?

      Which Of These Business Issues Can You Most Identify With?

      Why ASEAN Companies Need To Be Better Storytellers

      Why ASEAN Companies Need To Be Better Storytellers

      3 Leadership Nuggets From Sarawak Chief Minister Abang Johari

      3 Leadership Nuggets From Sarawak Chief Minister Abang Johari

    • Books
      Don’t Fall For The Common Myth That Stops People From Making Real Change

      Don’t Fall For The Common Myth That Stops People From Making Real Change

      Are You Still Searching For The Elusive Work-Life Balance?

      Are You Still Searching For The Elusive Work-Life Balance?

      What You Can Do To Master Your Professional Relationships

      What You Can Do To Master Your Professional Relationships

      Is Empathy A Bad Decision-Making Guide For Leaders?

      Is Empathy A Bad Decision-Making Guide For Leaders?

    • LDR Show
      How You Can Break The Old Cycle Through Intentional Leadership

      How You Can Break The Old Cycle Through Intentional Leadership

      The Leaderonomics Show: 'In The Culture Of Innovation, It's Okay To Fail.'

      The Leaderonomics Show: 'In The Culture Of Innovation, It's Okay To Fail.'

      The Leaderonomics Show: ‘Learn From The Experts,’ Says Baroness Michelle Mone

      The Leaderonomics Show: ‘Learn From The Experts,’ Says Baroness Michelle Mone

      The Leaderonomics Show: ‘Business Is About Positive Impact,’ Says Paul Leibold

      The Leaderonomics Show: ‘Business Is About Positive Impact,’ Says Paul Leibold

    • Leadership Nuggets
      Leadership Nuggets: Worry Not When We Fail

      Leadership Nuggets: Worry Not When We Fail

      Leadership Nuggets: The Best Way To Learn

      Leadership Nuggets: The Best Way To Learn

      Leadership Nuggets: The Power Of Mind Elasticity

      Leadership Nuggets: The Power Of Mind Elasticity

      Leadership Nuggets: Start By Saying 'Yes, Please!'

      Leadership Nuggets: Start By Saying 'Yes, Please!'

    • Movie Wisdom
      Life Lessons From <i>Goodbye Christopher Robin</i>

      Life Lessons From Goodbye Christopher Robin

      5 Leadership Lessons From Hercule Poirot In <em>Murder On The Orient Express</em>

      5 Leadership Lessons From Hercule Poirot In Murder On The Orient Express

      How Batman Turns His Greatest Fear Into His Biggest Strength

      How Batman Turns His Greatest Fear Into His Biggest Strength

      Hey, Look Who We Have On <i>The Leaderonomics Show</i>. It's Batman In The House!

      Hey, Look Who We Have On The Leaderonomics Show. It's Batman In The House!

    • Soundbytes
      Empathy: An Understanding That One Size Doesn't Fit All

      Empathy: An Understanding That One Size Doesn't Fit All

      Playing To Win: Organisation Excellence

      Playing To Win: Organisation Excellence

      Fitness: The 'Unseen Elephant' In The Leaders Life

      Fitness: The 'Unseen Elephant' In The Leaders Life

      Raise Your Game: Getting Corporate Culture Right

      Raise Your Game: Getting Corporate Culture Right

    • Women & Leadership
      'Let's Rethink Our Approach To Education, And Collaborate To Compete!' Says Anne Tham

      'Let's Rethink Our Approach To Education, And Collaborate To Compete!' Says Anne Tham

      Learning From The Top 4 Asian Female Philanthropists

      Learning From The Top 4 Asian Female Philanthropists

      4 Leadership Lessons From Margaret Thatcher

      4 Leadership Lessons From Margaret Thatcher

      Just Give Your Best Shot, Always!

      Just Give Your Best Shot, Always!

  • Personal
    • Character
      Creativity: Beyond The Box

      Creativity: Beyond The Box

      How To Stand Your Ground While Facing The Critics

      How To Stand Your Ground While Facing The Critics

      Do You Have The Will (To Prepare) To Win?

      Do You Have The Will (To Prepare) To Win?

      5 Rude Emails You’re Sending Without Realising It

      5 Rude Emails You’re Sending Without Realising It

    • Values
      Follow Your Gut Feeling, Not The Money Trail

      Follow Your Gut Feeling, Not The Money Trail

      How Has Technology Made Work-Life Balance Easier?

      How Has Technology Made Work-Life Balance Easier?

      To Be A Better Leader, Listen With <i>Ting</i>

      To Be A Better Leader, Listen With Ting

      Can You Serve And Lead At The Same Time?

      Can You Serve And Lead At The Same Time?

    • Competence
      5 Highly Effective Negotiation Tactics Anyone Can Use

      5 Highly Effective Negotiation Tactics Anyone Can Use

      How You Can Win Hearts And Minds Through Your Presentation

      How You Can Win Hearts And Minds Through Your Presentation

      5 Steps For Finding Your VOICE As A Leader

      5 Steps For Finding Your VOICE As A Leader

      How Do You Go About Collecting Competencies That Set You Up For Life?

      How Do You Go About Collecting Competencies That Set You Up For Life?

  • Soundbytes
  • Free E-mag
  • Videos
  • About Us
  • Follow
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Youtube
    • Instagram
Home
Personal
Personal Growth

Why Being Engaged At Work Isn’t As Simple As ‘Being Happy’

January 12th, 2018 Personal, Personal Growth

Share this article

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Pinterest
Why Being Engaged At Work Isn’t As Simple As ‘Being Happy’Personal

By MARK C. CROWLEY

 

In December 2013, Gallup researchers stunned the business world with the revelation that just three in 10 workers in the United States (US) are engaged in their jobs and willing to do all they can to help their bosses and organisations succeed.

In the nine months that followed, a hyper-focus on restoring engagement had become a fully-fledged movement in the US, with many companies committing themselves to boosting employee happiness as their chosen remedy.

Like a doctor who had made a dire diagnosis and then wasn’t consulted for proper treatment, Gallup had grown alarmed that the pursuit of happiness had so many leaders embracing a tonic that will not help businesses get better.

In 2014, I sat down with Jim Clifton, Gallup’s chief executive officer (CEO), and asked him to provide his prescription for bringing American workplaces back to full health.

Leveraging insight gained from Gallup’s decades-long global engagement and wellbeing studies, not to mention his own work with hundreds of companies across the world, he offered this often contrarian advice:

We shouldn’t be trying to make workers happy

“The idea of trying to make people happy at work is terrible,” Clifton told me emphatically.

While admiring companies like Zappos, which intentionally fosters positive workplaces, he nevertheless believes a day-to-day focus on the fun aspects of happiness greatly miss the mark.

This is because Gallup’s research shows that how a person feels about the work they do every day has the greatest impact on engagement by far.

“What companies will inevitably find is that the only way to make a person happy is to give them a job that matches well to their strengths, a boss who cares about their development, and a mission that gives them feelings of purpose,” Clifton said.

“The belief that something gets better when you come and do your job, that’s as happy as you can be.”

Studies in positive psychology help to validate this and show that true contentment is tied to human flourishing.

According to Shawn Achor, author of The Happiness Advantage: “Happiness is the experience of positive feelings of pleasure combined with deeper feelings of meaning and purpose.”

Happiness is the joy we feel when we’re striving to fulfill our potential and accomplishing something significant.

Free lunches don’t drive achievement

“Free lunches and snacks have little direct impact on human performance,” Clifton insists, “and have the real potential of being destructive to achievement.”

On a vacation to Yellowstone National Park, Clifton noticed signs saying: “Do Not Feed The Bears,” almost everywhere he went.

Concerned that all these postings were an indication that bears were mauling campers in unusual numbers, he sought out a park ranger for explanation.

“Those signs aren’t for your protection,” the ranger told him, “they’re there to protect the bears. What most people don’t understand is that when you feed a bear a peanut butter and jelly sandwich, they’ll never dig for roots again.

“Park visitors think all they’re doing is giving the bear a treat, but they end up ruining all those great animal’s lives.”

Clifton believes we need similar signs in a lot of American companies.

“Rather than looking for all the ways that actualise people, they’re focused on free food. And that’s not only what people don’t want – it’s what’s going to spoil them.

“The ultimate act in workplace leadership is human development, not a focus on happiness or entertainment.”

Perks aren’t much better at driving engagement

It’s perhaps a surprise that Clifton is not a fan of the “Best Places To Work” rankings annually published in Fortune magazine.

It’s because he believes we too often herald organisations for being generous with perks when the spotlight should be placed on the companies who make more meaningful investments in growing their people.

“Many companies like Google offer perks because they create conveniences for employees,” says Clifton.

“But there’s no cause and effect in terms of engagement and high performance. I think perks make a little bit of difference to people, but the benefit is granular compared to a focus on individual expansion.”

Clifton, nevertheless, strongly advocates that organisations provide employees with health care and on-site day care.

“Offering these is the right thing to do; both greatly enhance wellbeing, which is known to have a direct and positive impact on the bottom line.”

Engagement is driven by what many CEOs still believe are soft practices

“What businesses really want,” says Clifton, “is for employees to bring their initiative, commitment, and productivity to their jobs; but we can’t find any evidence that pay plays much, if any, role in driving this.

“The true connections are what many business leaders instinctively consider soft practices. But it’s almost as if the softer you go, the stronger the signal. The softer you go, the stronger the correlation.”

All of the questions that Gallup asks workers about their engagement, Clifton told me, “are really about a human wanting to develop, maximise their strengths, make a meaningful contribution, and feel valued. And we know that engagement happens automatically when these deeper needs get met.”

But traditional beliefs about how best to motivate human beings continue to be the key reason why 70% of the working population in the US is disengaged.

“The truth is that many CEOs have been repelled by this idea that management must incorporate more heart to be successful,” Clifton says.

“But now, many are saying: “come a little bit closer, my dear.” And this is because CEOs are desperate to win.

“They’re beginning to recognise that an authentically caring culture provides a clear and sustainable competitive advantage.”

So goes the manager, so goes engagement

When I asked Clifton where organisations should start if their objective is to build deep and lasting engagement across their enterprises, he was direct and unambiguous.

“Going forward, we must insist on hiring caring managers. Managers must be driven, love productivity, profitability, and competing,” he added, “but they must also have an inclination to maximise the potential of every person on their team.”

Gallup has discovered that organisations too often make the mistake of promoting people into managerial positions simply because they were most senior, or they’d previously been star individual performers.

But their research shows that unimaginable success comes when companies demonstrate greater discipline – and courage – by selecting people who have the proven motivation of making a difference in the lives of others, not just their own.

“The final question companies should ask each time they’re considering a managerial candidate is this: Do they offer leadership or do they need leadership? It’s a big difference,” Clifton says.

 

Mark spent over 25 years as a senior executive in financial services, and now is a leadership speaker and consultant. His book, Lead From The Heart, is now being taught at four American universities. Send us your thoughts about employee engagement by emailing us at editor@leaderonomics.com.

LDR-PDF-download-110x110

 

 

 

Share this :

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Tags
  • CEOs
  • Gallup
  • jim clifton
  • mark c crowley
Next article How You Work Matters, But What You Work On Matters A Lot More
Previous article 8 Traits That Are Making You A Bad Employee and Colleague

Related Posts

Supporting Those Who Support You Be a Leader

Supporting Those Who Support You

Employee Engagement Excellence Business

Employee Engagement Excellence

7 Mindsets Of CEOs From A To F Leadership

7 Mindsets Of CEOs From A To F

5 Reasons Why Employees Quit Functional

5 Reasons Why Employees Quit

AmGeneral: Top Talents Speak Out Business

AmGeneral: Top Talents Speak Out

Leadership

Women Leaders- So What? Celebrating The (Very Slow) Death Of Gender Stereotypes

By LILY CHEAH Let's talk about women, and more specifically, women in leadership positions at work....

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Bahasa Malaysia | English

Pick of The Week

Apr 13th 3:00 PM
Our Pick Of The Week

How SPARK Camp Changed The Lives Of My Students

Apr 11th 9:31 PM
Leadership

Our Transformational Journey Of Authentic Leadership To The Roslin Orphanage

Apr 10th 12:00 AM
Functional

Does Every Company Need To Be A Technology Company?

  • Business
  • Functional
  • Leadership
  • Personal
  • Soundbytes
  • Free E-Mag
  • Videos
  • About Us
  • Back to top

About Leaderonomics.com

Leaderonomics.com is a leadership portal owned by Leaderonomics, a social enterprise passionate about transforming nations through leadership development. Leaderonomics.com features leadership insights, trends, CEOs, thought leaders, HR leaders and inspiring real-life stories for your personal and professional development.

Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy      
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed on this website are those of the writers or the people they quoted and not necessarily those of Leaderonomics.
[Sitemap | RSS]
Copyright © 2010-2017 Leaderonomics Media Sdn Bhd. All rights reserved